GAMERATERCrowning the greatest game of all time

Vote Rankings Members Guides Rivals

Discord Forums Patreon

LIVEJoin / Log in

RIVALRIES

The big matchups gamers argue about, and where the community's votes put each side.

World of Warcraft artwork

Final Fantasy XIV artwork

VSWorld of Warcraft#187 overallFinal Fantasy XIV#34 overall

World of Warcraft vs Final Fantasy XIV: which MMO wins?

59%20 votes41%14 votes

More rivalries

The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim cover art

The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt cover art

The Elder Scrolls V: SkyrimThe Witcher 3: Wild Hunt#1 overall#16 overall73%61 votes27%22 votes RPG

Games: Votes Today: Total Votes:

votes today0

Your Votes: Day Streak: 0

News About FAQ Contact Support Privacy Game data by IGDBIGDBVersion 1.8© 2026 Gamerater

Elden Ring cover art

VS

Dark Souls cover art

Elden RingDark Souls#4 overall#185 overall65%37 votes35%20 votes

Grand Theft Auto V cover art

Red Dead Redemption 2 cover art

Grand Theft Auto VRed Dead Redemption 2#240 overall#186 overall53%23 votes47%20 votes

Fortnite cover art

Apex Legends cover art

FortniteApex Legends#692 overall#777 overall71%24 votes29%10 votes

Street Fighter II cover art

Mortal Kombat cover art

Street Fighter IIMortal Kombat#546 overall#569 overall39%7 votes61%11 votes

Minecraft: Java Edition cover art

Terraria cover art

Minecraft: Java EditionTerraria#76 overall#659 overall77%55 votes23%16 votes

Doom cover art

Wolfenstein cover art

Doom (2016)Wolfenstein#104 overall#842 overall89%34 votes11%4 votes

Doom cover art

Wolfenstein 3D cover art

Doom (1993)Wolfenstein 3D#63 overall#1230 overall96%45 votes4%2 votes