GTA V vs Red Dead Redemption 2: which Rockstar game wins?
Updated October 27, 2026
LEADS59%Grand Theft Auto V16 votes41%Red Dead Redemption 211 votes
Total votes for each game on Gamerater. Ranks are live.
Same studio, five years apart. GTA V came out in 2013 with three playable heroes, big heists, and GTA Online, which kept it going for years. Red Dead Redemption 2 followed in 2018 and slowed everything down: a huge, detailed Western and the story of Arthur Morgan.
The case for GTA V: it is a blast, the heists are great, and GTA Online gives it endless life. The case for Red Dead Redemption 2: the detail, the story, and a world that feels alive.
Right now the community has Grand Theft Auto V ahead of Red Dead Redemption 2. The ranks above are live, so they move with every vote.
Pick a side.